When Should You Drop Collision Coverage on Your Car? A Comprehensive Guide

Navigating car insurance can sometimes feel like solving a puzzle, right? One question that often pops up is, “Should I keep or drop my collision coverage?” Let’s break it down: collision coverage helps cover the repair or replacement of your car after an accident. But, just like with any service, there comes a time when the cost might not match the benefit.

So, let’s dive into this guide where we’ll explore when it makes sense to say goodbye to that part of your policy. By the end, you’ll have a clearer picture, ensuring you make the best decision for your pocket and peace of mind.

Jump here:

    1. When you rarely use your car
    2. When your car’s actual cash value is low
    3. When insurance premiums exceed 10% of your car’s value
    4. When you can cover repair costs out of pocket
    5. When expected repair expenses are less than your deductible
    6. When it’s better to replace your car than repair it after an accident

When Should You Drop Collision Coverage on Your Car?

When Should You Drop Collision Coverage on Your Car?

 1. When you rarely use your car

For those who infrequently drive, the likelihood of encountering an accident significantly drops. Moreover, with the advent of ridesharing services and public transportation becoming more efficient, many people find themselves relying less on personal vehicles. 

When your car is more a resident of your garage than the streets, the cost of collision and comprehensive coverage might seem unnecessary. This might be especially true for homeowners who have multiple vehicles or for those who live in urban settings where driving is less of a necessity. 

This scenario leads many to wonder, “When should I drop collision insurance?” If your car journeys are more the exception than the rule, it might be time.

 2. When your car’s actual cash value is low

Cars depreciate, and the market value of your vehicle today might not be what it was when you purchased it. Factors like mileage, wear and tear, and older car models can further decrease a car’s worth. 

When potential post-accident repair costs compare to or even exceed the current value of your car, reevaluating your collision insurance covers becomes essential. One can refer to resources like Kelley Blue Book to ascertain the current value of their vehicle.

 3. When insurance premiums exceed 10% of your car’s value

A standard rule of thumb in the car insurance sphere is if your annual collision insurance cost surpasses 10% of your vehicle’s value, you might contemplate whether to drop collision coverage. This calculation becomes particularly pertinent for older vehicles where insurance costs might not equate to the protection you’re truly receiving.

 4. When you can cover repair costs out of pocket

If you’re in a robust financial situation where an emergency fund is accessible, or you have credit cards to handle unexpected repair costs, you might consider dropping full coverage car insurance

Moreover, those who have a habit of saving or investing might find themselves in a position where paying for repairs out of pocket is more cost-effective than monthly insurance premiums.

 5. When expected repair expenses are less than your deductible

With a high deductible in place and the projected repair costs from potential damages falling below this amount, maintaining collision coverage might not be economical. It’s always wise to evaluate the average cost of collision repair for a specific car model and juxtapose that against your chosen deductible.

 6. When replacing, not repairing, your car post-accident is the plan

If you’d rather buy a new car than fix a heavily damaged one, then collision coverage might not be as important for you. In such scenarios, setting aside what you would’ve spent on premiums for a newer car purchase might be a smarter financial decision.

Factors Before Dropping Collision Coverage

When Should You Drop Collision Coverage on Your Car?

Car insurance can be a tricky maze. When thinking about whether to keep or let go of your collision coverage, a few important factors come into play. Let’s dive into what you should consider before making that choice:

  • Age and Value of the Car: Newer or more expensive vehicles often warrant continued coverage. While older cars have their charm, their diminished value and vulnerability to significant damage might not justify collision coverage.
  • Risk Tolerance: Gauge your comfort with the risks of not having collision and comprehensive insurance. For some, peace of mind holds immense value, making this a pivotal consideration.
  • Loan Requirements: Lenders might mandate collision coverage if there’s an ongoing loan on the vehicle. Before making any changes, reviewing any contractual obligations with your lender is imperative.

What to Do After You’ve Decided to Drop Your Car’s Collision Coverage?

What to Do After You've Decided to Drop Your Car's Collision Coverage?

Thinking about dropping your car’s collision coverage? It’s a big step, but before you finalize anything, there are some things you should do. Here’s a quick rundown of what’s next:

  1. Consult with your insurance agent or broker: They can offer insights and help clarify the ramifications. A trusted insurance agent can give a holistic view of your coverage and its true benefits.
  2. Review your insurance policy details: Ensure understanding and that no penalties are attached. Some insurance companies may have specific clauses or penalties for changes, making this a vital step.
  3. Ponder upon a gradual coverage reduction: This could be a middle ground, reducing rather than completely dropping coverage based on your comfort. For instance, you could opt for a higher deductible initially, and as your car ages, consider further reductions..


Swift decisions don’t pair well with insurance matters. When mulling over, “when should you drop collision coverage on your car,” it’s imperative to evaluate your vehicle’s unique attributes and your fiscal stance. 

Engaging with professionals like StormWise can provide deep insights into car repair costs and considerations. Car owners should always feel secure on the road. Together, let’s ensure you’re driving the most informed path forward.

Secure your car’s future and guarantee top-notch care. Dive into our services and discover how StormWise can be your guiding compass.


the auto hail repair experts at StormWise

Want To Get Your Car Dent Free Again?

StormWise Insurance Help

Insurance Navigation

We work with all reputable insurance companies and will help take care of your claim, inspection, and deductible.

StormWise Satisfaction Guarantee

100% satisfaction guaranteed

Rest assured with a free estimate, a free rental car, and a lifetime warranty. We can arrange free car pickup or delivery, too!

StormWise Expert Advice

Expert Advice

Ask any questions you have about automotive hail repair and our process. You can also get an estimate via online chat.

Contact StormWise To Get Your Car Dent-Free

Tell Us About Your Car
Where Should We Send The Quote?